Phoebe and Caleb’s love story seemed perfect until an encounter with Caleb’s ex, Patty, stirred unexpected tension.
The couple had reconnected after nearly two decades apart and had been happily married for over two years. “Better late than never,” Caleb joked at their wedding. But a casual night out took a turn when Patty claimed, “I’ll always be your favorite girlfriend,” sparking discomfort in Phoebe.
Later, Patty accused Phoebe of being “jealous, immature, petty,” feeling pushed out of Caleb’s life. Caleb reassured his wife, affirming, “Phoebe, you’re my favorite, and that’s why I married you.”
Seeking resolution, they met Patty, who admitted feeling hurt but promised to respect their relationship. “Let’s take it one step at a time,” Caleb urged, as the trio agreed to move forward, with Phoebe hopeful about their future.
