The 2023 Provincial Golden Glove Championship in Quebec stirred controversy as Canadian boxer Katia Bissonnette withdrew from a match against transgender athlete Mya Walmsley. The last-minute decision ignited a broader discourse on the inclusion of transgender athletes, delving into safety, identity, and fairness.

Bissonnette, initially set to compete, learned late that Walmsley was a transgender athlete. Concerned about Walmsley’s competitive history as a female boxer in Quebec, she withdrew. Bissonnette cited safety risks, referring to a 2020 study showing higher impact from male blows.

Walmsley criticized Bissonnette for involving the media instead of addressing concerns directly. He advocated trust among athletes regarding gender identification. Bissonnette called for transparent rules and separate gender categories for fairness and safety.

The incident underscores the intricate challenges facing sports organizations, athletes, and policymakers in navigating transgender inclusion while ensuring fair, inclusive, and safe competitions.